Ava DeBartolomeis
← Back

Case Study Project

Ithaca to Go Checkout Redesign

Design a more effortless checkout experience

Duration
1 week sprint
Role
Product Designer
  • Mobile UI/UX Design
  • Checkout Experience
  • Design Systems
Ithaca to Go Checkout Redesign

Overview

After a nightmare experience using Ithaca to Go's mobile app, I was determined to create an improved checkout flow.

Problem

Ithaca to Go's app (rated 2.5 stars) gave so little feedback through checkout that I doubted every step, and deleted it after one order.

My role

In a solo visual design project, I redesigned four parts of ordering, from cart to post-order updates, and built a reusable design system guided by Material Design and Apple's HIG.

Impact

A clearer, more playful checkout with visual feedback at every step. It hasn't been tested with users yet, which is my next step.

I recently used the Ithaca to Go mobile app for the first time to order food to be delivered. I had previously only used the website to order food, which was never pleasant, however, the app was much worse.

After barely making it through the checkout experience, I felt motivated to design an intuitive experience. This mini passion project was solely focused on advancing my visual design skills.

The Problem

If the 2.5 star rating on the App Store was not telling enough, I have highlighted the key user pain points when advancing through the checkout flow. I kept these insights in mind as I began my design explorations.

Order placement pain points

Checkout pain points

Competitive Analysis

To gain inspiration from more successful checkout experiences, I looked at other food delivery services: GrubHub, Instacart, and Uber Eats.

Uber Eats

GrubHub

Instacart

These are the key differentiators in the competitive checkout experience:

Standardized usability guidelines
Automation
Visual feedback
iOS integration
Clean and simple designs

All of these elements come together to facilitate a much more intuitive experience that I felt Ithaca to Go desperately needed.

Final Designs

I targeted a redesign of four key aspects of the ordering process that were unsuccessful in Ithaca to Go's app:

  1. Browsing/Adding to Cart
  2. Uploading Payment Method
  3. Specifying Delivery Details
  4. Post-Order Updates

Browsing/Adding to Cart

Uploading Payment

Delivery Details

Delivery Updates

The Design System

I created a Design System with reusable components for a cohesive UI design and efficient prototyping process. I was inspired by various design system resources, like Google's Material Design System and Apple's Human Interface Guidelines.

High Fidelity Demo

Image needed: Interactive prototype video walkthrough

What I Learned

UX standards protect business value

After a bad experience, users switch apps. My DoorDash- and Grubhub-shaped expectations weren’t met, so I deleted the app for good.

Visual feedback is key

I constantly doubted my progress in the original app, so I prioritized keeping users informed at every step.

Standard UI principles

Referencing resources like Material.io kept my designs user-friendly and approachable.

Visual design skills

After process-heavy projects, I focused on clean, playful visuals using color, shape, and shading.

Moving Forward

This was a quick passion project, so I'd next:

Test with real users

Compare my redesign against the original app, since it reflects only my own experience so far.

Design the post-order flow

Receiving the food matters most, so users need more assurance after ordering, informed by user interviews.

Pitch it to Ithaca to Go

Use the research findings as leverage for a redesign proposal.

More Projects

Back to top ↑